Homes for sale in Nibley, UT

80 listings

Save this search

Sign in to save this search

We email you a link, and then you save it with one click.

Continue with Google Continue with Facebook

or get a link by email

Your name

Your saved homes go to one Top Hill agent, who can help when you’re ready. Nothing else is sent to you unless you ask for alerts.

80 homes on the market in Nibley right now. 2 of them are new this week. The median asking price is $499,900.

Nibley is a city in Cache County, incorporated in 1935, located between Hyrum and Logan in Cache Valley.

Asking $269.9K – $1.8M

New

1 / 26

$499,900 3 days on market 4 bd 2½ ba 2,202 sqft 1308 W 3350 S, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Intermountain Properties

1 / 34

$499,999 7 days on market 4 bd 1¾ ba 1,618 sqft 936 W 2730 S, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of XA Realty Group, LLC

1 / 19

$449,990 9 days on market 3 bd 2 ba 3,147 sqft 673 W 2840 S #23, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of D.R. Horton, Inc

1 / 31

$675,000 10 days on market 5 bd 3½ ba 3,874 sqft 3462 S 620 W, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Peaks

1 / 18

$444,990 10 days on market 3 bd 2 ba 2,793 sqft 665 W 2840 S #24, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of D.R. Horton, Inc

1 / 23

$479,990 10 days on market 4 bd 2½ ba 2,888 sqft 662 W 2840 S #21, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of D.R. Horton, Inc

Price cut $10K

1 / 16

$499,900 14 days on market 4 bd 2½ ba 2,237 sqft 252 W 2900 S #711, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Visionary Real Estate

1 / 17

$661,900 14 days on market 4 bd 2½ ba 2,631 sqft 3230 S 1125 W, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Kartchner Homes, Inc

Price cut $10K

1 / 59

$520,000 17 days on market 4 bd 2½ ba 2,356 sqft 3298 S 1000 W, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Abode & Co. Real Estate LLC

1 / 33

$329,900 18 days on market 3 bd 2½ ba 1,524 sqft 276 W 3075 S, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Visionary Real Estate

1 / 19

$1,785,000 18 days on market 3 bd 1¾ ba 2,812 sqft 5035 S Hollow Rd, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Century 21 N & N Realtors

1 / 39

$489,000 20 days on market 4 bd 2 ba 2,126 sqft 2750 S 660 W, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Realtypath LLC (Cache Valley)

1 / 17

$479,900 20 days on market 3 bd 2 ba 1,555 sqft 3357 S 960 W, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Excel Realty Inc.

1 / 13

$529,900 21 days on market 4 bd 2½ ba 2,439 sqft 228 W 2920 S #718, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Visionary Real Estate

1 / 23

$494,900 24 days on market 3 bd 2½ ba 2,166 sqft 249 W 2920 S, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Visionary Real Estate

Price cut $1K

1 / 13

$691,900 27 days on market 5 bd 2½ ba 3,134 sqft 3248 S 1125 W, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Kartchner Homes, Inc

1 / 32

$598,000 Under contract 28 days on market 5 bd 2½ ba 2,558 sqft 1259 W 2890 S, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Abode & Co. Real Estate LLC

1 / 4

$699,900 28 days on market 6 bd 4½ ba 3,601 sqft 3381 S 960 W, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Excel Realty Inc.

1 / 15

$589,900 28 days on market 4 bd 2½ ba 2,616 sqft 3337 S 1000 W #6017, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Excel Realty Inc.

1 / 37

$549,900 30 days on market 4 bd 2½ ba 2,430 sqft 289 W 2980 S #813, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Visionary Real Estate

Price cut $5.1K

1 / 42

$304,900 33 days on market 3 bd 2½ ba 1,547 sqft 2400 S 1275 W, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Achievement Realty, LLC

Price cut $20K

1 / 34

$399,999 36 days on market 3 bd 2 ba 1,199 sqft 3360 S 1416 W, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of KW Unite Keller Williams LLC

1 / 32

$515,000 Under contract 44 days on market 3 bd 2½ ba 2,017 sqft 1430 W 3410 S, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Cornerstone Real Estate Professionals, LLC

Price cut $28K

1 / 20

$469,500 45 days on market 5 bd 3 ba 2,548 sqft 695 W 3480 S, Nibley, UT Listing courtesy of Dwell Realty Group, LLC

The market in Nibley today

From the listings for sale, as of October 26, 2026. Asking prices only: Utah does not make sold prices public.

62for sale

18under contract or backup

$499,900median asking price

$221median asking price per sq ft

65median days since listed

42%have lowered their price

19new in the last 30 days

Listings for sale by asking price

13< $400K
20$400K–$500K
15$500K–$600K
8$600K–$700K
3$700K–$900K
3$900K+

Homes for sale by style

Two story or more30
Rambler / ranch14
Townhouse11
Split-entry1
Bungalow / cottage2
Other2

Questions about this market

How many are for sale in Nibley?: 62 right now, and 18 more under contract.
How much are sellers asking in Nibley?: Half ask less than $499,900, half more.
Are prices coming down?: 42% of the listings for sale have lowered their price at least once.
How long have listings been on the market in Nibley?: The listings for sale today were listed a median of 65 days ago.

Neighborhoods in Nibley

Ridgeline Park 22 for sale · $294.9K–$549.9K Nibley Coach 13 for sale · $444.99K–$564.99K

Living in Nibley

7,328residents (2020)

$499,900median asking price

5named parks

Location and Layout

Nibley lies between the cities of Hyrum and Logan in Cache Valley and has a total area of 4.03 square miles. ¹ The city is included in the Logan, Utah-Idaho Metropolitan Statistical Area. ¹

Housing and Schools

Listings in Nibley include properties in subdivisions such as Hawk Hollow, Ridgeline Park, Nibley Coach, Nibley Meadows, Sunrise Meadows, and others. ³ The city is served by the Cache school district. ³

When was Nibley incorporated?: Nibley was incorporated in 1935.
What is the total area of Nibley?: Nibley has a total area of 4.03 square miles, all land.
What school district serves Nibley?: The Cache school district serves Nibley.

Listing data is provided by UtahRealEstate.com and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All data has not been verified by broker or the MLS.

Filters